yoman

引用:

原帖由 tsomlay 於 2014-5-21 20:07 發表


philip xiao has just beaten clarence chew ( who beat wong chung ting a few weeks ago in tokyo  )
So how is Hong Kong better than New Zealand?

邊有得gum 計
今次去澳洲個6個人都好過philip xiao好多

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:14 發表

邊有得gum 計
今次去澳洲個6個人都好過philip xiao好多

donˊt think so.

yoman

引用:

原帖由 tsomlay 於 2014-5-21 20:19 發表


donˊt think so.

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

F1Hunter

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 21/5/2014 20:28 發表

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

Agree

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:28 發表

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

i am talking about new zealand.

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:28 發表

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

Nz players like TengTeng Liu and philip xiao can give Hong Kong players a run for their money, except mainland players who migrated to HK.

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:28 發表

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

Then how come powell beat kwan man ho 4:0 today?

[ 本帖最後由 tsomlay 於 2014-5-21 20:52 編輯 ]

tszchun

The reason why Wong Chun Ting lost to Clarence Chew in Tokyo was because Wong was under immense pressure to take the match to put HK in the lead against Singapore, while Chew, realizing that his team is the underdog, knew that he has nothing to lose. So results of the matches between two players do not usually really determine who is the better player. That's the reason why we would still support the same players regardless of their match histories.

So in determining who is better between HK and NZ:  using the Xiao d. Chew d. Wong result would most probably not give us the answer

yoman

引用:

原帖由 tsomlay 於 2014-5-21 20:43 發表


Nz players like TengTeng Liu and philip xiao can give Hong Kong players a run for their money, except mainland players who migrated to HK.

現在的香港本地球員 如黃鎮廷 何鈞杰 林兆恆
水平都追上了中國外援 甚至起越他們
u18水平水平在asia前列位置
可能你大多在oceania不太了解asian甚至世界的水平
phillip xiao 在wttc division3只是出任三号位置
不否認他有機會沖擊本地球員
但機會不高 有望跟mak king ho, kwan man ho打下
但對其他絕對下風

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:28 發表

唔通wong chun ting win kenta twice
Kenta win ma lin twice
then wong chun ting win ma lin?
乒乓波唔系gum 計架
其實australia 仲系division 2中游
平心而論 同香港既水平仲有段距離 尤其是青少年

kenta only beat ma lin once when Ma Lin was near his retirement. Not twice.
He lost to ma lin most of the time.

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 20:54 發表

現在的香港本地球員 如黃鎮廷 何鈞杰 林兆恆
水平都追上了中國外援 甚至起越他們
u18水平水平在asia前列位置
可能你大多在oceania不太了解asian甚至世界的水平
phillip xiao 在wttc division3只是出任三&#2149 ...

it would be difficult for Hk to hold on their division 1 status if they donˊt use china
imports like teng peng, giang tianyi and leung chu yan.

yoman

比賽勝負其實甚麼都有可能發生
只可以比較穩定性 or 整體戰積等
可能待本公開賽結果後可再比較大洋洲球手跟香港球手
況且香港只派出五位單打
大洋洲則派了21位
不否認liu dingding是前省隊 大概有甲b甲c實力  跟林 李 孔 關 mak 相約
但跟黃 何 還有一定距離
你頭先又叫人唔好比較imported athletes
liu dingding不也是引進的吧

yoman

引用:

原帖由 tsomlay 於 2014-5-21 21:03 發表


it would be difficult for Hk to hold on their division 1 status if they donˊt use china
imports like teng peng, giang tianyi and leung chu yan.

順帶一提 我其實有信心以本地球員取代 梁 張 等球員 效果必定更佳

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 21:03 發表
比賽勝負其實甚麼都有可能發生
只可以比較穩定性 or 整體戰積等
可能待本公開賽結果後可再比較大洋洲球手跟香港球手
況且香港只派出五位單打
大洋洲則派了21位
不否認liu dingding是前省隊 大概有甲b甲c實力  跟 ...

philip xiao and tengteng liu
migrated to nz when they were still kids. i think

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 yoman 於 2014-5-21 21:07 發表

順帶一提 我其實有信心以本地球員取代 梁 張 等球員 效果必定更佳

香港唔用imports 好大chance 跌 div 2.
甘多年打 div 1 因為有 china imports. similar to singapore.

tszchun

I think Leung Chu Yan was not invited directly from China to play in HK. He migrated to HK and played at the local championships and won the title. So the HK Team invited him; i think that was 1996. (not sure with the facts) HK did not really get any significantly good results from him until 2003.

Jiang Tianyi came to HK in 2005 i think? He was not even 18 then... 好似仲被人話係‘逃兵’因為他

Tang Peng.. HK was responsible for keeping him at this competitiveness... at age 33, he is now ranked at #19

I think you get the point... HK trained these "imports."

tszchun

2001 大阪世乒賽

香港男團 排列21名。只是13年前的事，沒有二十年

tsomlay

引用:

原帖由 tszchun 於 2014-5-21 21:19 發表
2001 大阪世乒賽

香港男團 排列21名。只是13年前的事，沒有二十年

無大陸高手今日可能打緊 div 2.

yoman

LIU Tengteng ^^ (NZL)    ?  3.6  
http://www.ittfranking.com/cgi-b ... gteng&submit=Go
^^     Indicates the player is not eligible to represent the Association in World Title,
    Continental Title and International Team events
that means he moved to nzl for less than 7 years

tszchun

是不是指 高禮擇 和 李靜？
他們都是陳江華教練辛辛苦苦練出來的。陳教練從德國引入歐洲的技術（因為當時歐洲的技術還不落後），帶「孖寶」四處參加比賽。最後在雅典奧運奪銀牌，在多哈亞運奪冠

我認為他們是香港高手。他們到現在還在為香港隊效力。